Fire Door Guide

Should a failed fire door be repaired or replaced?

Repair a failed fire door unless it cannot be shown to be a fire door, or the leaf, frame or glazing is damaged beyond repair to its tested specification. Most faults are gaps, seals, closers and hinges, and those are repairs. A door that has been cut for a vent or services, or has unconfirmed glazing, is replaced.

By Sebastian Grabowski, DC Fire & Security, Luton. Updated November 2026.

How often do failed fire doors really need replacing?

Not often. About 8% of the doors we inspected were recommended for replacement, and on the three repair programmes we have finished, 5% were replaced (7 of 147). The rest were put right on site.

The reason is simple. The most common faults are small ones: gaps round the frame, missing or painted-over seals, a closer that does not shut the door, missing signs. Each is a repair, not a new door. Our fire door inspection statistics show how the faults break down.

ResultFigureSample
Failed doors repaired rather than replaced95%140 of 147 doors, 3 finished programmes
Doors recommended for replacement at surveyAbout 8%About 35 of 448 doors, 6 surveys
Repair actions needed per failed door1.5671 actions on 435 doors

Questions that settle it, door by door

A decision on the whole building is a bad decision. Each door answers a short list of questions, and the answers tell you which way to go.

QuestionIf yesIf no
Can the door be shown to be a fire door, by a label, plug, certificate or installation record?Carry onReplace, because looking like a fire door is not proof
Is the leaf free from holes, delamination and rot?Carry onReplace the leaf
Is the frame sound, firmly fixed and matched to the leaf?Carry onRe-set or replace the frame
Is the glazing marked and in good order?Carry onReplace the glazing, or the door
Has it been cut or planed beyond what its evidence allows?ReplaceRepair
Will repair leave it matching its tested design?RepairReplace

A door that fails the first question is not worth repairing, however good it looks. That is why the evidence step comes before any quote.

When is repair enough?

Repair is enough when the door is a genuine fire door and the fault can be brought back to the standard it was tested to. That covers most gaps, seals, closers, hinges, signage and ironmongery.

Age alone is not a reason to replace. The government guidance for blocks of flats expects a door that met the standard when it was made to keep giving adequate protection, provided it is undamaged and the gaps are not too large. A repair has to leave the door as good as the tested design, so we photograph it before and after and record what was done.

  • Gaps between the leaf and the frame over 4mm, or a gap under the door over about 8mm
  • Intumescent strips and smoke seals missing, damaged or painted over
  • Self-closers that are missing, too weak or leaking
  • Loose or missing hinges, or the wrong type
  • Missing fire door signage
  • Locks, latches and hold-open devices that are not suitable

When does a fire door have to be replaced?

Replace the door when it is not a fire door in the first place, or when the damage cannot be repaired to the tested specification. Looking like a fire door is not enough.

These are the cases that ended in a replacement doorset in our work:

Reason to replaceWhat we found
Not fire-resisting constructionIn a primary school, 8 of 47 doors looked like fire doors but were not of fire-resisting construction
Cut for ventilation or servicesIn a block of flats, all 4 riser cupboard doors had been cut for ventilation, which destroys the fire rating
Glazing that cannot be confirmed as fire ratedIn a hotel, 20 escape-route doors had glazing we could not confirm
Damaged or delaminated leaf, rotten frameThe door fails again after repair, or the frame cannot hold the fixings
Gaps too large to close within tolerancePlaning or packing would take the leaf below its tested thickness

Repairs that are not really repairs

Some work looks like a repair but takes the door out of its certification. These do not count as a fix.

  • Planing a leaf to fit a moved frame, when the frame was the problem.
  • Filling a damaged edge with filler or foam.
  • Painting over seals to hide a gap.
  • Cutting a vent, a larger letterbox or a viewer hole through a leaf.
  • Fitting ironmongery that was not part of the tested assembly.
  • Re-hanging a door repeatedly with the same hinge and the same loose screws.

If the only way to bring a door back in line is one of these, the door needs replacing.

What do repair and replacement cost?

It depends on the fault, the size and type of building and how many doors are done on one visit. A repair is usually a fraction of the price of a new doorset, and doing many doors together brings the cost per door down.

A complete certified FD30S doorset, supplied and fitted, typically starts from around £3,000 + VAT, and glazed, FD60, double or premium doorsets cost more. We confirm a fixed price for fire door repairs and installs once we have seen the doors. For how prices are built up, see fire door supply and fit costs and fire door remedial costs.

If it has to be replaced

Choose a plain certified doorset, fitted as a set with its frame, over a mix of a new leaf in an old frame. Raised panels, routed mouldings and decorative inserts can void the tested rating, so a plain door is the safe route for a replacement. A new leaf in an existing frame is only sound if the frame is in good order and matches the specification the leaf was tested with. Ordering takes weeks, so plan the escape-route doors first, and make safe the doors that will wait. Our guide to fire door installation covers what a new doorset involves.

How do you decide, door by door?

Start with a door-by-door inspection that records the construction, the certification and the faults. The report then separates repairs from replacements, so you only pay for a new door where one is needed.

This is why a survey first usually saves money. We have seen blocks priced for full replacement where inspection showed most doors could be repaired. Our fire door inspections come with a photo report on every door, and a failed fire door inspection explains what to do once you have one. Where repairs are needed they follow from the report, and the work is described on our fire door repairs page. Repairs and new doorsets that need a third-party certificate are done by our BM TRADA / FIRAS-certificated contractors.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to repair or replace a fire door?
Repair is usually cheaper. A new certified doorset costs more than most repairs, though the exact difference depends on the fault and the type of door.
Does an old fire door have to be replaced because of its age?
No. Age alone is not a reason. The condition, the evidence and whether it still matches its tested design decide it.
Can a fire door that has been cut for ventilation be repaired?
No. Cutting a hole in a fire door destroys its rating, and it normally has to be replaced with a certified doorset.
Can I replace only the leaf and keep the frame?
Sometimes. The frame has to be sound, fixed firmly and match the specification of the new leaf. If the frame has moved or does not match, replace the whole doorset.
How do I know if my door is a real fire door?
Look for a certification label or plug on the door edge, and ask for the installation record. If neither exists, an inspector has to confirm the construction, and a door that cannot be proven usually has to be replaced.
Is a door that has been repaired as good as a new one?
It should be, if the repair returns it to its tested specification. A good repair is recorded with before and after photographs so the next inspector can see what was done.
Who decides whether a door is repaired or replaced?
The inspector records the evidence door by door, and the responsible person decides using the report. Ask for the reason behind each replacement so you can challenge it.

Send us photos or your report

Email your report or photos to info@dcsecurity.co.uk, or use the form. We usually come back with a fixed price the same day. Luton, Bedfordshire, Hertfordshire, Buckinghamshire and London.

Request a free quote

Send photos for a fixed price · No obligation · Response within 24 hours