By Sebastian Grabowski, Managing Director — fire and security systems for residential blocks across Bedfordshire, Hertfordshire and London since 2010. Updated June 2026.
One of the most misunderstood questions in residential fire safety. The answer surprises most landlords and managing agents: in a purpose-built block with a stay-put strategy, a communal fire alarm is usually the wrong thing to install.
Usually no. Purpose-built blocks of flats designed for a stay-put strategy should normally not have a communal fire alarm system — national guidance advises against it because it undermines stay-put and breeds false-alarm complacency. Each flat needs its own BS 5839-6 detection instead. Communal detection is needed where it operates smoke vents (AOVs), in converted houses without proper compartmentation, and in buildings moved to simultaneous evacuation. Your fire risk assessment makes the call.
The right answer depends on how the building was constructed and what evacuation strategy its fire risk assessment supports.
Usually NO communal alarm
Purpose-built blocks rely on compartmentation — each flat is a fire-resisting box. National guidance for purpose-built blocks of flats specifically advises against communal fire alarm systems where a stay-put strategy applies, because a sounding alarm encourages everyone to evacuate into the very escape routes the strategy keeps clear, and repeated false alarms breed dangerous complacency.
Detection only — no sounders
Many blocks have smoke detectors in corridors and lobbies that exist solely to trigger automatic opening vents (AOVs) and keep escape routes clear of smoke. This is a smoke control system, not a fire alarm — it operates silently with no sounders, and residents are often unaware it exists. It must still be maintained.
YES — mixed system common
Houses converted into flats that don't meet modern Building Regulations standards often cannot rely on compartmentation. Housing fire safety guidance (LACORS) typically calls for a BS 5839-6 Grade A mixed system: smoke detection in communal areas and heat detectors in each flat, sounding throughout the building so all residents evacuate together.
YES — and possibly BS 8629
Where a fire risk assessment has moved a building from stay-put to simultaneous evacuation — common where cladding or compartmentation defects are found — an interlinked alarm system covering all flats and communal areas is needed (it replaces waking watches under NFCC guidance). New residential buildings over 18m in England also require a BS 8629 evacuation alert system for fire service use.
Whether a block needs communal detection is not a matter of opinion or habit — it follows from the building's construction, compartmentation and evacuation strategy, all assessed in the fire risk assessment required under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 (as clarified by the Fire Safety Act 2021). If your assessment is out of date, or a contractor has proposed a communal alarm without reference to it, get the assessment reviewed first. We carry out PAS 79-2 fire risk assessments for residential blocks and install whatever the assessment actually calls for — including detection-for-AOV systems, Grade A mixed systems in conversions, and BS 8629 evacuation alert systems.
We work with managing agents, freeholders and RTM companies across Bedfordshire, Hertfordshire and London — fire risk assessments to PAS 79-2, detection and smoke control maintenance, conversions to BS 5839-6 Grade A systems, and BS 8629 evacuation alert installations. Straight answers first, quotes second.
Free initial advice · No obligation · Response within 24 hours